Papa Daves Pizza

Love this place, great crust and sauce, and their cheese blend is amazing. The options on the menu are awesome, and you can build your own. The Caesar salad is good, as are the Mozzarella Toast and Garlic Toast. When I feel like having a pizza of the non-thin crust variety, this is my go-to every time. Going to have to give the pasta's and lasagna a try some day.

The "All Meat Yummy" pizza is above-average for a meat-lover's. Not too greasy, and great flavours. The Hawaiian is good but nothing special. Lots of toppings on their pizzas. Slightly more expensive than other local pizza places, but worth it. Lol watch out if you have coupon. I was charged 1.5 pizzas with my BOGO coupon. It was an honest mistake (I think), and they fixed the bill.

I've been looking for an old fashioned, authentic type pizza I remember getting as a kid in the '90's. Nothing has really scratched that itch...until NOW! Papa Dave's pizza is SUPER YUMFUL! The toppings are generous and well placed, including the perfect amount of their 3 cheese blend. The dough is just the right thickness. It is tender and yet has a bit if that crisp mouthful when you bite into it. It is not greasy and yet not dry...it's perfect! Here's the true star...the SAUCE! It's not sweet, artificial tasting or lacking faith of flavour. It is savoury, rich in spices that will delight your palate and obviously authentic to the restaurant. I wish I could just butly the sauce for my own use at home, it's that good! Price is in league with any other establishment, which is pretty amazing when you consider the quality one gets! I can tell they make their pizzas with love and joy! There isn't online ordering through them directly, which is neat as I can't remember the last time I called a pizza place, so it added to the nostalgia. You can use Skip the Dishes if you want. I was able to text them through Google and ask questions, so that was cool. They allowed for a topping substitution without charging more. The pizzas I got were 2 large; 1 cheese lovers with pepperoni, salami and capicolli, and 1 Lean Beef a lovers with pineapple substituted in lieu of mushrooms. The pizza reheats well the next day in the oven. I won't be ordering from anywhere else, this is now my defacto pizza place. Plus they are a family owned small business, so supporting local is awesome! Well done Papa Dave's!

Can’t give zero stars. Most times when ordering on DoorDash they cancel the order without warning or explanation. Likely they’re just lazy and don’t want to make a pizza. It’s too bad cause the pizza is decent. Stopped ordering 5 months ago from there. And then all of a sudden craved a pizza and it was a mistake. Waiting for food for almost 2 hours now (cause reordering elsewhere takes time).

Be aware of their price and bad customer service. It was my first time ordering with this place and I did it through skip the dishes website for take out special. When I went for pick up, the owner said I paid the wrong price. I showed him the website and the price but he kept insisting and telling me the price changed two years ago and I have to pay $10 more for the difference. When I asked for the refund, he said he can make other pizza with the same price. I ended up take his offer but so disappointed with the customer service. I understand he can be frustrated, but as a business owner, it is his responsibility to check if delivery service website is showing the right price for his customers. And in the situation like this, even if it was not his intention, he should have apologize for the situation but he never did.

This restaurant clearly does not care about their customers. This review is coming from loyal customers who have been coming here for years. My partner grew up here in New West ordering this pizza. We absolutely love the quality of the sauce, meat, and dough of this pizza. It’s easily our favourite pizza here in New West. However, the customer service is abysmal. The only times we had a pleasant time is when dealing with the younger staff, or the owner himself. We actually resorted to ordering through DoorDash delivery, as we simply could not deal with how rude and unpleasant the older lady is. Tonight, they cancelled our order through DoorDash. After multiple orders throughout the months of our build it yourself option (which is a large pepperoni pizza), apparently an extra charge of $1.00+ would be warranted for having cheese and pepperoni. Every major pizza company with a build it yourself ordering feature, does not include cheese as a main topping. The base of the pizza is the dough, sauce, AND cheese. If you want EXTRA cheese, this would warrant the up charge. Your further toppings are then added up. We do not want “Pepperoni Yummy” we simply want regular pepperoni, which is not on their regular menu. Instead of reaching out to us and explaining the price would need to be adjusted as per their menu prices, they simply cancelled the order. How frustrating. Why is it put on the customer to compensate for your inconsistent prices? We have been ordering this way for months? How many times have we ordered a regular pepperoni pizza for pick up, and the price would flocculate based on who was working? How can deciding on a price for regular pepperoni pizza be this difficult? Not only that, but to have an attitude while providing subpar service just takes the cake. We ended up ordering from Papa Johns instead. The pizza is larger, with the price difference honestly not being that much more, with pleasant customer service. Thank you, Papa Dave’s, for another negative interaction with your restaurant!

Very tasty, ordered the hot and spicy pizza (actually had a kick), house special pizza, beef lasagna, side of meatballs with cheese. Everything on point. Sauce is good and crispy crust. The hot wings could have used more spice.

I feel bad writing this because I don’t write bad reviews. 1. The lady taking my order was quite rude on the phone. She kept interrupting me and wouldn’t let me finish a sentence. I looked past this. 2. I ordered two large pizzas and two lasagnas. They forgot a lasagna so I had to go back to get the other one. 3. When I finally sat down to eat, the first two bites of lasagna actually had good flavour (hence two stars), the sauce was good. Then I found multiple long hairs in it. What a total turn off. They did give me a refund for the one lasagna but man, what a disappointing night.