Goodys Pizzeria Bayside

Best Pizzeria in the area. Food tastes fresh and hand made. Love it.

I heard all kinds of good reviews about Goody's, so I decided to check it out after finishing work early. Walked in and ordered, took 12 mins for a fresh pizza with 3 toppings. Very fast, and the ladies were very helpful and wonderful! No complaints, and will be returning again!

Seriously best Greek salad I have had. Portions are huge and just delicious

disclaimer - this is an honest review of my personal experience I had with this place of business. Ordered A LOT of food and it didn't seem to bother them at all the motivation & attitude of the employees seemed un bothered and willing to take my order and ask specifically what I wanted as sides & condiments. order was: 3lb wings, x2 -> 2 for 1 1/4 Bacon cheeseburgers x2 -> bacon cheese burger combos with pop (onion rings & fries, 2 burgers with no tomatoes 2 other burgers with no hot peppers) a Greek salad (small) lets start with the wings. you'd swear these puppies came from the leg of the chicken and not the wings.. they're gigantic! Not only that but delicious :). medium sauce was well.. medium not too hot but just right. the Bacon cheeseburgers were good, they went cold quite quick but they were server hot! Nothing too fancy about the burgers and that's what it should be :). delicious, not too much of anything. the Greek salad was SO extra! didn't expect a small to be as large as it was but it was very delicious! it seems to have quite a bit of iceberg lettuce as a filler but none the less i don't think it took away from the salad itself. lots of feta, sauce, olives etc. they don't skimp out. the bacon cheeseburger combos were also great same burgers as the 2 for 1 but with sides! The onion rings were crispy and the fries weren't under or over salted, they also aren't soggy! yay! the total came to just under $90, it came with complimentary garlic bread and the lady that had made and handed us our food wish us happy holidays and a Merry Christmas. as first timers I give this 4.5 stars! a weird spot to get to as its right off highway 2 but none the less quality food from them! Thanks so much guys!

Great pizza, EVERY SINGLE TIME!!! I will drive the 10 minutes out of Belleville any day for this pizza. And the staff are always friendly.

Fantastic food, try to go here regularly as it's close to work. Can't beat the prices, and everything they make is always delicious. Highly recommend the Coney fries.

We were disappointed in our pizzas. We tried them a few years back and loved them. Last night the pizzas were very disappointing. The toppings were dry and fell off the pizza. The cheese was solid . It didn't have the melting quality that one thinks of with pizza. Nothing stretchy. One piece was enough for us and we won't be back.

I have normally enjoyed Goodies and it's service. I can not in good conscious support thus restaurant anymore. My last few experiences with them has been the worst ever. The servers are rude and they keep their phone of the hook. We placed an order inside for pick up after 30 mins not one thing was made. They serve their friends and family before the public. I would ask everyone to stop going there for 2 months let's see if they change their attitude when it comes to the community and not just their friends and family. Utterly disgraceful