Colonel Mustard's Pub & Grill

Name: Colonel Mustard's Pub & Grill
Address: 15 Water St, Port Perry, ON L9L 1H9, Canada, L, Canada

4/5 ★ based on 8 reviews

Contact Colonel Mustard's Pub & Grill

Address :	15 Water St, Port Perry, ON L9L 1H9, Canada
Phone :	📞 +998
Categories :	Bar & grill ,
City :	L

15 Water St, Port Perry, ON L9L 1H9, Canada

Best Bar & grill in Canada

D	Diane L'Allier on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Went for dinner tonight, spontaneous date night for us. Ordered a few things...garlic bread with cheese, nachos with beef, poutine and a garden salad. The food was typical of an average pub. The salad was fresh and the balsamic dressing delicious. However the poutine was ice cold in places, luke warm in others and hot in a couple of spots. Most of the poutine went untouched as it was not very edible, I was concerned that it was made with fries that had been sitting for some time. The rest of the food was decent enough. The nachos freshly fried it seems and the toppings were fresh though missing jalepenos and didn't really have that texmex flavour unfortunately. The beef topping was very different than expected, almost like a meat pie filling/gravy taste. The garlic bread was quite good, crispy edges and soft centre, the cheese fully melted and broiled a touch. The server was attentive and offered to warm up the poutine (I declined as it just gets soggy). She returned to check in between 6 and 8 times throughout the meal. All that to say that we will not likely return, the bill came wrong and needed to be fixed, and even though the poutine was not properly cooked we were charged for it. The rest of the food was average. Our booth was near the restrooms which we didn't realize when we chose it and unfortunately there was periodically bathroom smell that wafted out. The menu is very broad which in a time that most menus are limited was refreshing, however there were not enough positives to make us want to return for a second visit.
K	Kris on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Really hit or miss. Went today and was given dirty dishes so we left. But we went in the summer and it was fantastic. So I don't know what happened. Maybe a change of staff? I don't know. Don't plan on going back again until summer though.
Z	Zabrina Glen on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Had the cottage pie. Was super delicious ? great stop when passing thru Port perry:-)
J	Jason Wright on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Stopped in here on a whim for a couple drinks and some dinner. The food was very good however the overall cleanliness of the dishes and the high traffic surfaces themselves could use a little more attention. Not deplorable by any means but a little more attention to detail would make this place standout from it's local competitors.
T	Terry Mason on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Saw my Stepdaughter finally for Christmas. Food was great. Large portions. Fish and chips amazing. Quesadillas perfect. What I thought was Shepherds pie was unusual. Won't try that one again. Service is great and so are the prices.
D	David D on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Came Sunday night for dinner. Has been a while since being here, never had entrées here before only Wings and tacos. Had Bacon Wrapped stuffed chicken. Well nothing in the chicken was stuffed the bacon asparagus and peppers were ontop with a slice of half melted cheese. Salad piled into the chicken sauce. Also had the Chicken Tikka Masala Well the rice was dry/old. Not very flavourful.. Won't be back for anything other than wings... Maybe the menu should be smaller if they can't make everything as it should be.
Y	YYZREVIEW on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Ask the local where I could grab good food as a lot of the restaurants in the area close after 9: 00pm and this place was recommended. The staff was very helpful very friendly I didn't catch her name the food was excellent was told they're famous for their chicken wings and if you like jumbo chicken wings they have them here nice little local bar pub with very very good food with lots of selection worth the try if you're in the area.
F	Fanny Z on Google ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ This is a very, very good restaurant. The waiters here have a very good attitude, because there are many of us, including children, who are noisy. They don't mind and are friendly. We'll come to dinner next time, and the food here is also delicious.